To car or not to car is not the question. The question is to car and not pollute the air. The "ODD-EVEN" idea of Delhi Government is asking for many raised eyebrows, though the idea is not a new one it has been implemented successfully in the past too the only difference is, that was not in India, where every change is looked upon with a doubt first, then forced half heatedly and then discarded after labeling it a flop idea most cleverly by the opposition. Here are some countries who adopted this idea for the similar reasons.
- Athens, Greece in 1982
- Santiago, Chile in 1998 and extended to 2001
- Mexico City, Mexico in 1989
- Sao Paulo, Brazil in 1997
- Bogota, Colombia in 1998
- La Paz, Bolivia in 2003
- San Jose, Costa Rica in 2005
- Honduras (countrywide) in 2008
- Quito, Ecuador in 2010
While there are pros and cons to implementing road space rationing, pollution has reached dangerous levels in Delhi. You will remember that the air was not considered good enough for President Obama to breathe during his last visit to India.
In many ways Odd-Even number plates may be just the beginning. If we have to go by what the world has already learnt, there are many other ways to implement road space rationing, which may eventually eventually befall Delhi and other cities in India if the current idea does not work well enough.
Low Emission Zone, Car Free days, Congestion pricing, and Traffic Calming are other ways in which to reduce air pollution.
Low Emission Zone : An area is defined for low emission with the aim of improving air quality in that particular area typically one that has much higher pollution levels.
Car Free days : Where Motorists are encouraged to give up their cars for a day. Mumbai is already experimenting with a variation of this on Linking Road on Sundays for a few hours. It is likely to happen in other areas as well.
Congestion Pricing : Where users are charged a premium to enter certain high traffic areas. For example in some cities in the world there is an extra price to pay to enter the CBD area of the city.
Traffic Calming : Speed bumps and other measures like narrowed roads to slow down the traffic. Unfortunately in India narrow roads and bumps to slow down cars have been in existence for other reasons for many years.
Odd Even Rationing : Which is a method of rationing where roads are available only to half the population on a given day which is the current system being proposed by the State Government in Delhi.
Can Rationing Backfire ?
Road rationing in China for the Olympics was a huge success which led to a permanent implementation. In this instance, it produced direct, positive results. However, in some countries, specifically in Central and South America, some families have multiple cars. This is one of the methods that families use to get around these restrictions.
A report published entitled, The Day Without a Car in Mexico City, found that families purchased multiple cars and none of the intended benefits were met. In fact, due to the additional cars, total congestion and driving increased across the city.
Overall if we look into this, there are some logical reasons due to which many a commuters should be exempted from this rule but at the same time there are some societies where they started working on it and they will be car-pooling from next month and in that way there will be only 8 cars instead of 32, if more and more citizens opt this kind of tactics, I believe we can assure the supply of fresh breathable air for the generations to come.

No comments:
Post a Comment